• Home
  • Blog
  • Community
  • Knowledge
  • Cover Stories
  • Startup Stories
  • Playbooks
  • Podcasts
  • Português
    • Events Homepage & Booking
    • Start-Up Night Africa Series
    • Lioness Lean In Series
    • Lionesses of Africa Annual Conference
    • Harvard University / Lionesses of Africa Conference
    • Young Lioness Lean In Series
    • About Us
    • Impact Partners
    • Contributor Team
    • Contact
    • Join the Community
    • Signup for FREE Newsletters
    • Share Your Startup Story
    • Share Your Lioness Launch
    • Share Your Lioness Co-Lab
    • Become a Contributor
    • Nominate to '100 Lionessess'
    • Become an Impact Partner
    • Contact LoA
Menu

Lionesses of Africa

276 5th Avenue
New York, NY, 10001
(212) 634-4540
The Pride of Africa's Women Entrepreneurs

the pride of Africa's women entrepreneurs

Lionesses of Africa

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Community
  • Knowledge
  • Cover Stories
  • Startup Stories
  • Playbooks
  • Podcasts
  • Português
  • Events +
    • Events Homepage & Booking
    • Start-Up Night Africa Series
    • Lioness Lean In Series
    • Lionesses of Africa Annual Conference
    • Harvard University / Lionesses of Africa Conference
    • Young Lioness Lean In Series
  • About +
    • About Us
    • Impact Partners
    • Contributor Team
    • Contact
  • Connect +
    • Join the Community
    • Signup for FREE Newsletters
    • Share Your Startup Story
    • Share Your Lioness Launch
    • Share Your Lioness Co-Lab
    • Become a Contributor
    • Nominate to '100 Lionessess'
    • Become an Impact Partner
    • Contact LoA

Are Criminal Record Checks Relevant to Your Employee Screening Process?

June 9, 2024 Melanie Hawken

by Jenny Reid

Criminal record checks are one of the world’s leading forms of pre-employment checks. Should you be able to deny a candidate employment based purely on their criminal record check?

Globally, there is a massive movement called "Ban the Box" aimed at removing the checkbox on job applications that asks about an applicant's criminal history. The initiative is intended to give ex-offenders a fair chance at employment by delaying questions about criminal convictions until later in the hiring process. The reason for this is that employment provides individuals with a sense of purpose, structure, and responsibility. All of which are crucial for rehabilitation and successful reintegration into society. A job can also offer stability and opportunities for personal growth, helping ex-offenders break the cycle of crime and contribute positively to their communities.

This may be a valid notion in the global sphere; however, South Africa may differ. In South Africa, conviction rates can vary depending on the legitimacy of the justice system, the type of crime, the effectiveness of law enforcement, and various other factors. The availability of evidence often influences conviction rates, the strength of legal arguments, the efficiency of investigations, and the judicial process. In South Africa, the lack of a criminal record may not be indicative of an individual’s criminal intent or their potential for malicious behaviour.

Additionally, reporting and recording practices can impact the accuracy of conviction rate statistics, and we need to remember that South Africa faces challenges related to crime, including high rates of violent crime, property crime, and many other offences.

This leads us to question whether South African companies should conduct criminal record checks on candidates, at all.

Many people will swear high and low, that running criminal record checks is a necessary pre-employment check:

1.Legal Compliance / Regulatory Requirements: Certain industries and positions may require employees to undergo criminal record checks, as part of regulatory compliance. For example, industries such as financial services, childcare, security, healthcare, and education may have specific legal requirements regarding employee background checks.

2.Risk Mitigation: Conducting criminal record checks helps employers assess potential risks associated with hiring candidates who may have a history of criminal activity. This is especially important for roles that involve handling sensitive information, financial transactions, working with vulnerable populations, or maintaining public safety.

3.Safety and Security: Employers have a duty to provide a safe and secure work environment for their employees, clients, customers, and stakeholders. Criminal record checks can identify red flags or potential risks compromising workplace safety or security.

4.Trust and Reputation: Hiring employees with criminal records without conducting proper background checks can damage an organisation's trustworthiness and reputation within the eyes of their clients or the public at large. Clients, customers, investors, and partners may have concerns about working with a company that does not prioritise due diligence in employee screening.

5.Preventing Fraud and Theft: Criminal record checks can help prevent fraudulent activities, theft, embezzlement, and other misconduct within the organisation. Employees with a history of financial crimes or dishonesty may pose significant risks to the company's financial integrity.

Once companies have decided whether or not, a criminal record check is the right way to go and add these checks to their employee screening policy, it is essential that they understand the results and how to manage the information they receive.

Results can indicate no criminal history, and the candidate may have no criminal record. Still, it could also return varying forms of criminal history, and the consultant handling such information needs to understand the risk to the company in interpreting such data.

Examples of this have been seen in many formats and could be as simple as a candidate having been arrested and the incorrect data being captured by the South Africa Police Service. Information should be shared with the candidate, and the opportunity given to them to declare their details. They should be given the chance to prove that the details provided by the South African Police Service report are incorrect. They are entitled to get their personal information from a local police station and can provide their report to the potential employer.

There have also been cases where a candidate has declared their criminal record and either believes it has been expunged or is irrelevant to the job application.

Unfortunately, not all criminal records are eligible for expungement. Generally, minor offences, certain juvenile offences, and offences committed a long time ago may be considered for expungement. Serious offences, violent crimes, sexual offences, and repeat offences are typically not eligible for expungement. A recent labour court ruling allowed a candidate with multiple criminal charges and an expunged criminal record to be employed despite the employer considering the employment to be a risk to their organisation.

A second example is Oscar Pistorius, the South African athlete and former Paralympic champion, who was convicted of the murder of Reeva Steenkamp in 2014.  After serving his sentence, Pistorius must demonstrate rehabilitation and a commitment to reintegration into society. Still, like any individual with a criminal record, Pistorius may face challenges securing employment, especially in roles that require a clean criminal record or involve positions of trust, security, or public safety.  After being paroled, Pistorius allegedly reached out to members of the International Paralympic Committee, hoping to get a job, but was rejected.

When questioned about the relevance of criminal record checks in the pre-employment screening process in South Africa, Jenny Reid, founder of iFacts, stressed that whilst criminal record checks are a relevant check, it should never be the only check to be done on a candidate.

Other checks that could be considered would be integrity or social media risk assessments. Still, she said that an employee screening policy should ensure that an effective employee screening policy should consider the risks related to the position in the company. There were various elements to be considered when assessing such risk.

iFacts can assist in criminal record checks, as well as a bouquet of other pre-employment checks. We can also assist in the interpretation of the date received during the screening process. Hire with confidence, hire with iFacts.


Jenny Reid is a Human Risk Expert and Professional Speaker, and the owner of iFacts based in South Africa, a specialist employee screening and vetting service. She is constantly assessing new and innovative ways to remove the people risk in any organisation. Since 2009 when she took over iFacts completely, she has seen the company double in size and hopes to continue this growth. iFacts specializes in employee Screening, risk assessments, employee wellness, investigations, and truth verification. Jenny is a past President of the Security Association of South Africa. Contact Jenni via email jenny@ifacts.co.za

 

Read more articles by Jenny

Featured
South Africa’s unemployment crisis: challenges and imperatives for the recruitment sector
May 17, 2025
South Africa’s unemployment crisis: challenges and imperatives for the recruitment sector
May 17, 2025
May 17, 2025
Dumpster diving for data: Are you an easy target?
May 10, 2025
Dumpster diving for data: Are you an easy target?
May 10, 2025
May 10, 2025
Are you using a reliable integrity tool for your hiring process?
May 1, 2025
Are you using a reliable integrity tool for your hiring process?
May 1, 2025
May 1, 2025
World Backup Day: Who Makes Decisions Regarding Your Data Protection and Organisational Integrity?
Apr 13, 2025
World Backup Day: Who Makes Decisions Regarding Your Data Protection and Organisational Integrity?
Apr 13, 2025
Apr 13, 2025
Does your employee screening policy address cyber crime risks in your organisation?
Apr 5, 2025
Does your employee screening policy address cyber crime risks in your organisation?
Apr 5, 2025
Apr 5, 2025
Do no-experience-required jobs need background checks?
Feb 25, 2025
Do no-experience-required jobs need background checks?
Feb 25, 2025
Feb 25, 2025
Can South African HR leaders stop white-collar crime in their organizations?
Feb 13, 2025
Can South African HR leaders stop white-collar crime in their organizations?
Feb 13, 2025
Feb 13, 2025
Skills over degrees: Redefining job qualifications in South Africa
Feb 8, 2025
Skills over degrees: Redefining job qualifications in South Africa
Feb 8, 2025
Feb 8, 2025
The importance of the candidate experience during employee screening in South Africa
Feb 1, 2025
The importance of the candidate experience during employee screening in South Africa
Feb 1, 2025
Feb 1, 2025
Strengthening Employee Screening in South Africa: Key Observations from 2024
Jan 5, 2025
Strengthening Employee Screening in South Africa: Key Observations from 2024
Jan 5, 2025
Jan 5, 2025
Screen your house and pet sitters
Dec 6, 2024
Screen your house and pet sitters
Dec 6, 2024
Dec 6, 2024
Holiday Rental Safety
Nov 16, 2024
Holiday Rental Safety
Nov 16, 2024
Nov 16, 2024
In Guest Blog Tags Jenny Reid, People Management
← How to Remain Compliant While Keeping Track of all the Compliance Requirements of the Companies Act The Impact of Female-Owned Businesses and How They Contribute to Food Security in Africa →

CELEBRATING 10 YEARS


LATEST PODCAST

LIONESSES OF AFRICA · AI Series - Navigating Artificial Intelligence In The Workplace

Lioness Radio Show Special Episode: Navigating AI in the Workplace - Tune in for an engaging conversation designed to equip you with the knowledge to embrace AI and unlock its possibilities for your business.


LIONESS WEEKENDER COVER STORIES

LIONESS WEEKENDER COVER STORY
Zanele Njapha, a transformational business leadership coach
Zanele Njapha, a transformational business leadership coach
Mekdes Mesfin, a proudly Ethiopian fashion designer and manufacturer
Mekdes Mesfin, a proudly Ethiopian fashion designer and manufacturer
Emilia Chisango, a multi-faceted business empire builder
Emilia Chisango, a multi-faceted business empire builder
Morongwe Mokone, a passionate champion of artisanal homeware
Morongwe Mokone, a passionate champion of artisanal homeware
Tshego Molefi, a pioneer transforming the waste management industry
Tshego Molefi, a pioneer transforming the waste management industry

IMAGE OF THE DAY. CELEBRATING WOMAN MADE IN AFRICA.

Image of the Day / Adèle Dejak

Big bold accessories…We are big fans of luxury jewellery and accessories made with love and passion on the African continent, and Adèle Dejak in Kenya is the epitome of handmade luxury. The brand c
Image of the Day / ReelFruit
 
Healthy snack treats…We love showcasing Africa’s women agribusiness builders, and ReelFruit, founded by Affiong Williams, is inspirational - it’s the largest fruit processing, packaging and distributi
Image of the Day / Dokmai Rwanda

Made in Rwanda Handbag…A passion for handcrafted accessories, combined with a sense of pride for ‘Made in Rwanda’ products, inspired Dokmai Rwanda founder, Bernadette Umunyana, to create a company
Image of the Day / Eki Silk

Silk Serenity…Nothing is quite as luxurious as silk, that’s why we love the ‘Africa on Silk’ collections from Eki, founded by Hazel Eki Osunde. Her latest Deep Dive Collection is inspired by the p
Image of the Day / The Nanjala Company

Pot plants delivered… Give gifts that will last, such as these stunning plants in individual pots from The Nanjala Company in Kenya, founded by Teresa Nanjala Lubano. This online store creates customized
Image of the Day / Sari for Change

Sustainable Sari Glamour - If you want to wear a robe that makes you feel and look glamorous, then Rayana Edwards, founder of Harem in South Africa, has a range of fabulous robes all made from sari fabrics. She has
Image of the Day / MonChoco

Pure chocolate heaven…If you are a chocolate lover, then you need to experience raw chocolate at its finest, and Dana Mroueh, founder of MonChoco an artisan chocolatier in Côte d’Ivoire, has just what y
Image of the Day / Mulandi Brindes

Say it with flowers…If you want to make someone feel special, then there is no better way than with the gift of fresh flowers, and Mulandi Brindes in Mozambique, founded by Vanessa Guilherme Nhabete, creates
Image of the Day / Mariée Eventos

The Wedding Planner…Every big celebration day needs great organization, and that’s where Iris Lezi Munguambe, founder of Mariée Eventos in Mozambique, is your go-to person. She launched he
Image of the Day / Dounia Home

Statement lighting… from Dounia Home, the home of innovative, handcrafted and ethically made Moroccan lighting and home decor founded by Dounia Tamri-Loeper. Her company designs, produces and brings to market hi
Image of the Day / Adèle Dejak

Big bold accessories…We are big fans of luxury jewellery and accessories made with love and passion on the African continent, and Adèle Dejak in Kenya is the epitome of handmade luxury. The brand c Image of the Day / ReelFruit
 
Healthy snack treats…We love showcasing Africa’s women agribusiness builders, and ReelFruit, founded by Affiong Williams, is inspirational - it’s the largest fruit processing, packaging and distributi Image of the Day / Dokmai Rwanda

Made in Rwanda Handbag…A passion for handcrafted accessories, combined with a sense of pride for ‘Made in Rwanda’ products, inspired Dokmai Rwanda founder, Bernadette Umunyana, to create a company Image of the Day / Eki Silk

Silk Serenity…Nothing is quite as luxurious as silk, that’s why we love the ‘Africa on Silk’ collections from Eki, founded by Hazel Eki Osunde. Her latest Deep Dive Collection is inspired by the p Image of the Day / The Nanjala Company

Pot plants delivered… Give gifts that will last, such as these stunning plants in individual pots from The Nanjala Company in Kenya, founded by Teresa Nanjala Lubano. This online store creates customized Image of the Day / Sari for Change

Sustainable Sari Glamour - If you want to wear a robe that makes you feel and look glamorous, then Rayana Edwards, founder of Harem in South Africa, has a range of fabulous robes all made from sari fabrics. She has Image of the Day / MonChoco

Pure chocolate heaven…If you are a chocolate lover, then you need to experience raw chocolate at its finest, and Dana Mroueh, founder of MonChoco an artisan chocolatier in Côte d’Ivoire, has just what y Image of the Day / Mulandi Brindes

Say it with flowers…If you want to make someone feel special, then there is no better way than with the gift of fresh flowers, and Mulandi Brindes in Mozambique, founded by Vanessa Guilherme Nhabete, creates Image of the Day / Mariée Eventos

The Wedding Planner…Every big celebration day needs great organization, and that’s where Iris Lezi Munguambe, founder of Mariée Eventos in Mozambique, is your go-to person. She launched he Image of the Day / Dounia Home

Statement lighting… from Dounia Home, the home of innovative, handcrafted and ethically made Moroccan lighting and home decor founded by Dounia Tamri-Loeper. Her company designs, produces and brings to market hi

STARTUP STORIES. MEET THE WOMEN WHO’VE LAUNCHED.

Featured
Suné Theisinger and Dr Juanri Jonck, two dynamic players in the aesthetic industry in South Africa
Suné Theisinger and Dr Juanri Jonck, two dynamic players in the aesthetic industry in South Africa
Tania Kabeya, a passionate chef and entrepreneur building a uniquely African culinary brand
Tania Kabeya, a passionate chef and entrepreneur building a uniquely African culinary brand
Aasiyah Adams, a visionary South African tech founder helping individuals and organisations to thrive in the digital economy
Aasiyah Adams, a visionary South African tech founder helping individuals and organisations to thrive in the digital economy
Komeshni Patrick, a tech legal consultancy founder empowering forward-thinking tech businesses to grow
Komeshni Patrick, a tech legal consultancy founder empowering forward-thinking tech businesses to grow
Lebo Biko, a South African champion of women-led innovation in Africa’s agri-food value chain
Lebo Biko, a South African champion of women-led innovation in Africa’s agri-food value chain

LIONESS DATA & INSIGHTS


LIONESS PLAYBOOKS



Screen Shot 2020-01-27 at 6.01.32 PM.png
Screen Shot 2020-01-27 at 5.34.58 PM.png

Sign up today to receive the #1-rated newsletters for Africa's women entrepreneurs.

* indicates required
Required: Please select your newsletter(s):


LIONESS BOOK REVIEWS

Featured
Babette’s Bread by Babette Kourelos
Babette’s Bread by Babette Kourelos
SOS – A Navigation Guide for Women at Work by Lidewij Wiersma, Chantal Korteweg, Tessel van Willigen and Marijn Wiersma
SOS – A Navigation Guide for Women at Work by Lidewij Wiersma, Chantal Korteweg, Tessel van Willigen and Marijn Wiersma
Unstoppable Entrepreneurs: 7 Paths for Unleashing Successful Startups and Creating Value through Innovation by Lori Rosenkopf
Unstoppable Entrepreneurs: 7 Paths for Unleashing Successful Startups and Creating Value through Innovation by Lori Rosenkopf
Afro-Optimism Unleashed by Adeolu Adewumi-Zer
Afro-Optimism Unleashed by Adeolu Adewumi-Zer
No More 24/7: Entrepreneurs, Take Your Life Back by Catherine Cowart Roe
No More 24/7: Entrepreneurs, Take Your Life Back by Catherine Cowart Roe

About Us  |  Contact Us  | PRIVACY POLICY | terms OF SERVICE  | Community Guidelines  

© 2025 LIONESSES OF AFRICA public benefit corporation. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.