by Mandisa Makubalo
Ever heard of the word ‘cookie-cut?’ By definition, to cookie-cut is to indicate that each one is the same, like a guaranteed formula for something that works. It also means that the same approach or style is always used and not enough attention is paid to individual differences. Have you ever found yourself saying “I’m struggling to get the buy in of the C-Suite for my CX (Customer Experience) project”? Have you recently taken on a CX project as an independent consultant or entrepreneur? If your answer is yes, I invite to look as I discuss some of the reasons you might be experiencing the resistance and ways to overcome it.
Top 7 Reasons for Cookie-cut approaches
Coming in with the right answer or a pre-defined way of doing things
Predictability
Lack of questioning
Lack of understanding
Lack of knowledge capital
Getting involved in organizational politics
Inability to be adaptable
Let us look at each of these common mistakes:
1. Coming in with the right answer
Many CX leaders/professionals lack the ability to tailor their knowledge and methodologies to fit a specific situation. Just because your current client challenge sounds similar to your previous client challenge doesn’t mean that you stop listening to really understand. Organizations are looking for your advice and direction, at most times they are stressed, they really need your help but in order to deliver business value you are required to suspend your pre-defined way of doing things. Best practice is not always right, every organization and project is different, therefore the solution needs to look different to fit the organization.
2. Predictability
The COVID-19 pandemic has tested everything to do with predictability. We have seen how unpredictable life can be even for those who think they know it all. As a CX practitioner, consultant, leader etc. predictability is a recipe for failure, it leads to great frustration and missed opportunities. If solutions were as predictable as many would love to think, organizations would not require the external expertise of CX practitioners and CX wouldn’t be a key differentiator. The fact that organizations choose to make investment in CX teams and on expert skills of outside practitioners is evidence to the unpredictability of your work.
3. Lack of questioning
As professionals there is a combination of hard and soft skills required in order to solve the complex problems and challenges facing organizations. In order to respond to the different situations like a “chameleon” it is important to develop a number of soft skills especially the ability to question as this will allows you to read the client or your organization, build relationships, avoid cookie-cut approaches which could result in a number of implications from a cost and reputation perspective. You can never fully know everything and asking questions doesn’t mean that you’re incompetent in fact most clients and organizations applaud this level of maturity.
4. Lack of understanding
This is the major cause of the frustrations experienced by most organizations which has led to decisions being made in terms of investments in CX. When customers don’t feel understood by brands this results in a number of frustrations which impact on the employee’s ability to execute their roles efficiently and the build-up of these frustrations calls for interventions from either internal CX teams or external CX skills. When organizations do not understand the value of CX investments this results in reluctance and great push back from key decision makers. The ability to listen fiercely and question allows both the organization and the CX practitioner to develop deep understanding of the challenges facing the organization and allows you as the CX practitioner to direct and give advice to the business.
5. Lack of knowledge capital
The knowledge capital of CX practitioners is not only limited to CX knowledge, yes this is very important and CX wouldn’t be CX without the related industry knowledge. Demonstrating your expertise and speciality is determined by how well you add to the knowledge capital of others through knowledge share. The key to developing the needed knowledge capital is by stretching your brain, it’s an ongoing process of continuous improvement. CX solutions cannot be designed and delivered in isolation of broader business knowledge, be committed to learning about new technologies, AI, business processes, project management, change management, strategy, machine learning, new business industries, different types of cultures and operating models. The ability to tailor this knowledge capital and your methodologies to fit a specific organizational situation allows you to pay attention to individual organizational differences.
6. Getting involved in organizational politics
Your role as a CX practitioner / leader is to give guidance, direction and advice to organizations. Being clear on your role and always reminding yourself why the organization has brought you onboard will prevent you from getting involved in organizational politics. By definition organizations are stressed, they need your help from all the internal politics and other complex business challenges, your ability to listen the best and understand the best allows you identify the internal politics and come up with ways to enable business value.
7. Inability to be adaptable
Being an adaptive CX leader means you’re able to change your behaviour in response to changes in situations. You demonstrate resilience when things don’t go as planned and you’re able to bounce back from failure seeing it as an opportunity to learn. Cookie-cut approaches go against being an adaptive CX leader in that they are not flexible in nature, they are rigid, there is no room to access different ways of thinking and they inhibit you from shifting and experimenting as things change. Being an adaptable CX practitioner comes with a great amount of emotional intelligence and organizational justice which stretches you to respond to different organizational demands and pressure.
Closing Words
Non cookie-cut approaches require CX leaders who know how to:
embrace the diversity of views from all stakeholders;
evaluate views objectively and take advantage of the views that create business value;
let go of non-productive practices and strategies that are not supporting organizational goals and objectives;
link CX initiatives to the core value of the organization;
foresee resistance and reluctance to implementing new strategies and the ability to embrace and address resistance positively and
have the willingness to undergo the process of change.
CX leaders, like most leaders, work with a great amount of ambiguity. Be comfortable with it, have the ability to apply both head and heart, experiment with smart risk-taking, learn and adapt, creating win-win solutions, learning though reflection and take the time to navigate business environments.
Mandisa Makubalo is the founder of Unlimited Experiences, co-founder of WasteMinders, and Customer Experience Advocate. She is a highly experienced serial entrepreneur and change-maker. She is the founder of Unlimited Experiences SA, the first 100% black-owned customer experience management consultancy in South Africa, a business that helps companies become more customer experience centric. She is also the Co-Founder and CEO of a waste management non-profit organization called Waste Minders NPS, a company driving economic development through waste management and creating awareness around environmental degradation. Mandisa has studied and worked in customer environments for most of her professional career - her expertise lies in Strategic Planning, Design and Implementation and Service Excellence. Mandisa has been recognised and awarded for her exceptional leadership qualities throughout her career.
More articles by Mandisa
When organisations talk about wanting to set up a new business unit, there is often so much confusion within the organisation and outside the organisation. This confusion could be justified by the fact that most individuals both internally and externally are not part of the boardroom conversations where decisions are made. To some this decision is seen as a response to a business need; to some this introduction is met with great resistance as they feel left out and anxious about the thought of new people coming into the organisation. There’s concerns about who will be promoted, some immediately make accusations about unfair recruitment practices like “they already know who they want for those roles” which begins to threaten their relationship with the organisation.